Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (2024)

3.7

(127)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (1)

3.0

(20)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (2)

3.7

(127)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (3)

3.0

(20)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (4)

#12 on "The 16 best family restaurants in Wellsboro"

Pizza restaurant

Fast food restaurant

Italian restaurant

Delivery Restaurant

Restaurant

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (5)

Phone

(570) 724-4998

Hours

SuSunday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

MoMonday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

TuTuesday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

WeWednesday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

ThThursday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

FrFriday: 9:00 AM–10:00 PM

SaSaturday: 9:00 AM–10:00 PM

105 East Ave, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA

SuSunday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

MoMonday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

TuTuesday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

WeWednesday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

ThThursday: 9:00 AM–9:00 PM

FrFriday: 9:00 AM–10:00 PM

SaSaturday: 9:00 AM–10:00 PM

Hide times

People typically spend 10 min here

(570) 724-4998

About

Pudgie's Pizza is a reliable and steadfast eatery that offers an array of delicious whole pizzas and specialty slices, as well as delectable wings, subs, and calzones. The food is exceptional, with unbeatable prices that are truly astonishing. Whether you're traveling with your spouse or exploring alone, Pudgie's Pizza stands out as one of the finest dining experiences during your journeys.

Why you should go

    1

  1. Enjoy delicious pizza and wings at unbeatable prices
  2. 2

  3. Quick delivery options available
  4. 3

  5. Variety of six packs in the well-stocked beer cave

Menu and popular items

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (6)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (7)

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (8)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (9)

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (10)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (11)

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (12)Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (13)

Highlighted reviews

Slide 1 of 3

Great food and unbelievable prices!!! My husband and I travel all over and hands down some of the best food we’ve ate in travels. We only eat and shop local when traveling to support the local businesses in the area. A pizza like we got would have cost $50-70 in Las Vegas or New York!!! Can’t wait to travel through again someday 🖤🖤🖤 And those wings😮😮🖤

Go to pizza place with a beer cave. Nice staff with quick delivery options. The Subway is in the same store. Worth a call to order!

Great pizza joint. It's not too bad on the wallet either.

Great food and unbelievable prices!!! My husband and I travel all over and hands down some of the best food we’ve ate in travels. We only eat and shop local when traveling to support the local businesses in the area. A pizza like we got would have cost $50-70 in Las Vegas or New York!!! Can’t wait to travel through again someday 🖤🖤🖤 And those wings😮😮🖤

Go to pizza place with a beer cave. Nice staff with quick delivery options. The Subway is in the same store. Worth a call to order!

Great pizza joint. It's not too bad on the wallet either.

See all reviews

We gathered reviews from Google and Tripadvisor, and summarized helpful tips as well as commonly mentioned things others might find useful.

  1. Check for fresh pizza to avoid any issues with food sitting out too long
  2. Consider ordering early if looking for specific toppings as they may run out
  3. If dining in isn't an option due to limited seating space, you can sit at the adjacent Subway side
  4. Try their burgers which are precooked before ordering

Reviews

Pudgie's Pizza is a popular spot praised for its great food at unbelievable prices, with reviewers highlighting the delicious pizza and wings. Some caution about potential issues like food sitting out too long or running out of ingredients, but overall, visitors appreciate the quick delivery options and variety in the beer cave. The location shares space with Subway and offers a diverse menu featuring whole pizzas, specialty slices, wings, subs, and calzones.

Review score

3.7

out of 5

Good

127 reviews

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (14)From Google

Review score

3.0

out of 5

20 reviews

From Tripadvisor

5 stars

49

4 stars

29

3 stars

24

2 stars

9

1 star

16

5/5Rachel Filer

Great food and unbelievable prices!!! My husband and I travel all over and hands down some of the best food we’ve ate in travels. We only eat and shop local when traveling to support the local businesses in the area. A pizza like we got would have cost $50-70 in Las Vegas or New York!!! Can’t wait to travel through again someday 🖤🖤🖤 And those wings😮😮🖤

5/5Peter Lupkowski

Go to pizza place with a beer cave. Nice staff with quick delivery options. The Subway is in the same store. Worth a call to order!

5/5Curtis Copp

Great pizza joint. It's not too bad on the wallet either.

3/5Melissa Gifford

Beware of the pizza that is sitting out in the glass warmer. Both my husband & I ended up super sick (possibly food poisoning) after eating a slice of pizza each.

4/5James Oswalt

Everything was good, with the exception that they had run out of pepperoni for the Italian sandwiches.

Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (21)

All Google Maps reviews

All Tripadvisor reviews

What's the weather like in Ulster?

It depends on when you visit! We've compiled data from NASA on what the weather is like in Ulster for each month of the year: see the links below for more information.

  • Weather in Ulster in January
  • Weather in Ulster in February
  • Weather in Ulster in March
  • Weather in Ulster in April
  • Weather in Ulster in May
  • Weather in Ulster in June
  • Weather in Ulster in July
  • Weather in Ulster in August
  • Weather in Ulster in September
  • Weather in Ulster in October
  • Weather in Ulster in November
  • Weather in Ulster in December

Explore nearby places

  • Ulster
  • Towanda
  • Wysox
  • Athens
  • Rome
  • Sayre
  • Waverly
  • Chemung
  • Nichols
  • Granville
  • Warren Center
  • Troy
  • Granville Summit
  • Le Raysville
  • New Albany
  • Wyalusing
  • Sugar Run
  • Little Meadows
  • Owego
  • the Canton
  • Elmira
  • Laceyville
  • Dushore
  • Pine City
  • Apalachin
  • Friendsville
  • Millerton
  • Van Etten
  • Erin
  • Forksville
  • Elmira Heights

All related maps of Ulster

  • Map of Ulster
  • Map of Towanda
  • Map of Wysox
  • Map of Athens
  • Map of Rome
  • Map of Sayre
  • Map of Waverly
  • Map of Chemung
  • Map of Nichols
  • Map of Granville
  • Map of Warren Center
  • Map of Troy
  • Map of Granville Summit
  • Map of Le Raysville
  • Map of New Albany
  • Map of Wyalusing
  • Map of Sugar Run
  • Map of Little Meadows
  • Map of Owego
  • Map of the Canton
  • Map of Elmira
  • Map of Laceyville
  • Map of Dushore
  • Map of Pine City
  • Map of Apalachin
  • Map of Friendsville
  • Map of Millerton
  • Map of Van Etten
  • Map of Erin
  • Map of Forksville
  • Map of Elmira Heights

Ulster throughout the year

  • Ulster in January
  • Ulster in February
  • Ulster in March
  • Ulster in April
  • Ulster in May
  • Ulster in June
  • Ulster in July
  • Ulster in August
  • Ulster in September
  • Ulster in October
  • Ulster in November
  • Ulster in December
Pudgie's Pizza, Ulster, PA - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 6270

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.